So another way I am ruining my baby (besides formula feeding) is by following the “On Becoming Babywise” book. Parenting books are all, as far as I can tell, horrible, and this one is no exception. I also read “The Happiest Baby on the Block” and it is horrible in all the same ways that Babywise is. Both books could essentially be boiled down to 1500 word how-to articles, which would save everyone a lot of time.
The basic outline is to start out by telling you how the baby will change your life. Just flip past the first 3-5 chapters, trust me. Then, there are numerous “case studies” comparing babies who were raised using the book’s method to babies who were not. Invariably, these examples illustrate that following this particular book will produce a happy, healthy baby, while other methods will produce crying, whiny sociopaths and are tantamount to child abuse. About 2/3 of the way through is the actual meat of whatever method is being discussed, and then the conclusion just repeats everything one more time for people who have poor reading comprehension.
Obviously, most babies turn out to be happy and healthy, no matter what ridiculous parenting book or theory is used. For example, my parents used a method that was popular in their time, called “Put the baby in the corner and ignore it.” This worked pretty well for me (I am happy and healthy, and only a little neurotic), but I was looking for something a little more nurturing.
But also, most babies also turn out to be somewhat f-ed up adults, and there is nothing you can do about it. If you sleep in your parents’ bed until you’re 5, you’re going to be f-ed up in one way, and if your parents park you in a crib on the other side of the house, you will end up being f-ed up in another way. In this way, raising kids is both a win-win and a lose-lose proposition. On the one hand, there is nothing you can do to not mess up your kid. On the other hand, you have to really go out of your way to mess up your kid more than anyone else.
So back to Babywise. The Babywise method suggests getting your baby into a Feed-Wake-Sleep cycle as soon as possible. We achieved this in week 2. Mo’s cycles last 2-1/2 to 3 hours, and the only bad thing is that I occasionally do wake her up to eat after 3 hours during the day, which according to the “Put the baby in the corner and ignore it” method is extremely taboo. Needless to say, my mother does not approve. But, at three weeks, she is in a good routine, usually going 4 hours and 3-1/2 hours at night, so I can get close to 7 hours of sleep per night. Supposedly, she will begin sleeping through the night (7-ish hours) somewhere between week 6-8. We’ll see…
Babywise is controversial because of 2 types of people: People with poor reading comprehension and people who think women should not have any personal needs beyond nurturing a baby every minute of the day. I guess some babies have become dehydrated and failed to thrive because the first type of person reads Babywise and thinks that it says that you should only feed your baby every 3 hours, even if it’s hungry before then. Let me just say this: Yer doin’ it wrong.
The second type of person is a proponent of what is called “Attachment Parenting” which suggests that removing your baby from your nipples for even 10 minutes is child abuse. Interestingly, the Babywise authors suggest that Attachment Parenting is child abuse because it produces sleep-deprived, whiny babies. Can’t we all just agree not to call each other child abusers?
I didn’t actually get around to reading The Happiest Baby on the Block until after we discovered that swaddling the baby fixes everything. (Hard to read a book when your baby keeps CRYING.) Coincidentally, this book is a huge proponent of swaddling, so by the time I read it, I didn’t really need it anymore. There are 4 other recommendations for calming a fussy baby, but we didn’t need them so I won’t even waste your (my) time.