Opening: Electronic music plays over a montage of the contestants – they all wear judicial robes. The name and current job of each contestant pops up next to the photos, interspersed with words like “fierce,” “fresh,” and “fabulous.” The last photo is a group shot of 10 judges posing like models; all but three vanish from the photo. These are the final three.
Elena Kagan, U.S. Solicitor General, Former Dean of Harvard Law School
Kathleen Sullivan, Law Professor, Form Dean of Stanford Law School
Merrick Garland, U.S. Court of Appeals – Washington D.C. Circuit
The panel of judges – President Obama, Vice President Biden, Harry Reid and guest judge Kim Kardashian – sits at one end of the room. The three final contestants walk in and stand on the other end of the room.
BARACK OBAMA
Hello contestants. Of course you all know there is no “litmus test” for the highest court in the land, but if you want to be America’s Next Supreme Court Justice, you’ll have to show everyone that you know how to answer the tough questions. That’s why, in this week’s photo shoot, we challenged you to demonstrate your position on the controversial ruling of Roe Versus Wade.
Elena Kagan, you’re first.
Elena Kagan walks down the runway and approaches the judges’ table. Elena is played by a slightly overweight man in drag.
BARACK OBAMA
Elena… Are you ready to take a look at your photo?
ELENA KAGAN
Yes, Mr. President.
The photo shows Kagan, posed awkwardly with one arm out to the side, palm up, and the other hand on her forehead.
BARACK OBAMA
OK. I have to say, Elena… This is not your best photo.
JOE BIDEN
Oh man… I don’t know what you’re going for here. I mean, you clearly have some gender issues, but you do know what Roe v. Wade is, right?
KIM KARDASHIAN
I don’t know… I think I kind of like it. When I think of Roe versus Wade, this is exactly how I feel.
HARRY REID
I’m going to agree with Joe. It’s obvious from this picture that you have no judicial experience.
BARACK OBAMA
Let me just ask you a question, Elena. How do you feel about this shot?
ELENA KAGAN
I admit it didn’t really turn out how I’d hoped. I was trying to show the complicated nature of the ruling, but it just didn’t seem to come through.
BARACK OBAMA
When I looked at your film from this shoot, I saw a lot of good posing, but your face was just so self conscious. This just doesn’t have the “fabulosity” you’re going to need to be America’s Next Supreme Court Justice.
Kagan nods sheepishly.
BARACK OBAMA
OK… Next up is Kathleen Sullivan.
Sullivan approaches the judges table. Her mannerisms are scholarly, like a professor about to teach class.
BARACK OBAMA
Kathleen… Here’s your photo.
The photo shows Sullivan, hands on hips looking defiantly at the camera.
BARACK OBAMA
Woah! That’s just… You are just fierce in this photo.
HARRY REID
It’s very, almost… confrontational.
BARACK OBAMA
When I see something like this, it just reminds me of myself during the election, when I was just fighting for every vote. In this photo, you look fierce, just like I was. Don’t you guys think this is a very Obama-esque photo?
KATHLEEN SULLIVAN
The thrust of my argument here is towards a deeper understanding of the privacy issue surrounding Roe vs. Wade.
JOE BIDEN
Hah. Thrust… You do a lot of thrusting, do you?
KATHLEEN SULLIVAN
Excuse me?
JOE BIDEN
Well, you like the ladies, right? So who wears the pants, if you know what I mean?
KATHLEEN SULLIVAN
I don’t believe my sexuality is pertinent to the job, although I would be honored to be the first openly gay member of the Supreme Court.
JOE BIDEN
(laughing) OK, sweetie.
KIM KARDASHIAN
You know, you should try making a sex tape. That totally did wonders for my career.
BARACK OBAMA
Thank you, Kathleen. Merrick Garland. You’re next.
Garland approaches the judges table
BARACK OBAMA
Here’s your best photo.
The photo shows Garland sitting behind a judge’s desk, holding a gavel.
BARACK OBAMA
Wow. The gravitas in this photo… Merrick, you are the only one of the finalists to have served as a judge. It really shows through here.
KIM KARDASHIAN
(Flirting) Great photo…
HARRY REID
There’s just not much to say here. You really look the part.
BARACK OBAMA
One thing you need to work on is using your eyes to show emotion… For example, if I wanted to look like I was deep in thought, using just my eyes, I would do this:
(Obama’s face remains blank.)
OK? but here’s what you did:
(Obama’s face remains blank.)
Do you see the difference?
JOE BIDEN
I think it’s refreshing to see a man up here. I mean, why does everyone think America’s Next Supreme Court Justice has to be a woman or a Mexican or a gay? What’s wrong with a good old fashioned white protestant male?
MERRICK GARLAND
Actually, I’m Jewish.
JOE BIDEN
Jewish! You’re kidding! We already have two of those!
BARACK OBAMA
So. Now it’s time for us to deliberate. And, when I call you back… It will be time to announce… which one of you will be…
LIVE FROM NEW YORK, IT’S SATURDAY NIGHT.